Copycat Starbucks Birthday Cake Pop Creamer Recipe

8

This Starbucks Birthday Cake Pop Creamer combines the nostalgic taste of cake batter and vanilla buttercream, capturing the essence of those iconic Starbucks Cake Pops we’ve come to love. But what if I told you that you could make this luxurious treat at home?

How to make Starbucks Birthday Cake Pop Creamer

Starbucks Birthday Cake Pop Creamer is a flavored liquid coffee creamer made with real milk and cream, designed to add the taste of birthday cake to coffee.

Ingredients

Base Ingredients:

• 1 cup of whole milk – For a creamy texture. You can also use dairy-free alternatives like almond milk or oat milk.
• 1 cup of heavy cream: This thickens the creamer and gives it that luscious, smooth consistency.

Flavor Elements:

• 2 tablespoons of sweetened condensed milk – For sweetness and a richer flavor.
• 2 teaspoons of vanilla extract: Gives the creamer a classic vanilla cake profile.
• 1/2 teaspoon of almond extract – Adds a slight nuttiness and replicates the glaze flavor in actual cake pops.
• 2 tablespoons of white or golden sugar: Enhances the overall sweetness; you can adjust this based on your preference.
• 1 tablespoon of butter extract (optional) – This mimics the buttery texture of cake batter.

Colorful Option (Decorative):

• 1 teaspoon of rainbow sprinkles (optional) – Sprinkle on top for a festive finish when serving your coffee.

Instructions

1. Combine Milk and Cream: In a medium saucepan, combine the whole milk and heavy cream. Heat over low-medium heat, stirring occasionally. Be careful not to let the mixture come to a full boil—keep it warm, not hot.
2. Add Sweetened Condensed Milk: Stir in the sweetened condensed milk until it’s fully dissolved. This step ensures that your creamer has a silky, sweet consistency.
3. Incorporate Flavorings: Add the vanilla extract, almond extract, sugar, and optional butter extract. Whisk thoroughly to ensure all the flavors meld together.
4. Taste and Adjust: Once mixed, give it a taste. If you prefer it sweeter, add a little more sugar or sweetened condensed milk. If you like a stronger almond or vanilla flavor, adjust accordingly.
5. Cool the Mixture: Remove the saucepan from the heat and allow the mixture to cool to room temperature. Once cooled, transfer the creamer to a clean, airtight container or glass bottle.
6. Store and Use: Store your homemade Starbucks Birthday Cake Pop Creamer in the refrigerator for up to 7 days. Shake well before each use.

Tips for Making the Perfect Creamer

• Adjust Sweetness: This recipe is on the sweeter side, similar to the Starbucks creamer. If you want less sweetness, reduce the sugar or swap sweetened condensed milk for unsweetened condensed milk.
• Dairy-Free Option: Use full-fat coconut milk or cashew cream as a substitute for heavy cream, and almond or oat milk instead of whole milk. The flavor profile will still be rich and delicious!
• Presentation: Add rainbow sprinkles to your coffee cup for a festive touch, especially if you’re serving it to guests during a special celebration.
• Elevate With Whipped Cream: For an extra indulgent treat, top off your coffee with whipped cream and a few more sprinkles to simulate the cake pop experience.
• Experiment with Extracts: If you love bolder flavors, try experimenting with other extracts, like hazelnut or coconut, to customize your creamer even further.

Ingredients Substitutes

If you’re making your own Starbucks Birthday Cake Pop Creamer at home but are missing a few ingredients—or you’re looking for healthier or dietary-friendly alternatives—don’t worry! The recipe is versatile, and there are plenty of substitutes to match your lifestyle or pantry.

1. Whole Milk

Substitutes:

• Almond Milk: A great option for a lighter, dairy-free creamer. Opt for unsweetened vanilla almond milk to help maintain the vanilla flavor of the Starbucks Birthday Cake Pop Creamer.
• Oat Milk: Creamy and dairy-free, oat milk is a fantastic substitute because of its smooth, full-bodied texture.
• Soy Milk: Adds a thicker texture than other plant-based milks, making it ideal for recipes requiring creaminess.
• Coconut Milk: Use canned, full-fat coconut milk for the creamiest consistency. Note that it may add a coconut flavor to the creamer (which can be a bonus if you love tropical notes).
• Low-Fat Milk: If you’re watching calories, low-fat or skim milk can work, but the Starbucks Birthday Cake Pop Creamer won’t be as rich. Consider adding a little more heavy cream as compensation.

2. Heavy Cream

Substitutes:

• Coconut Cream: The thick portion of canned coconut milk works well as a dairy-free alternative. Whip it slightly for an ultra-thick, velvety texture.
• Cashew Cream: Cashews soaked in water and blended into a smooth cream provide a non-dairy, silky consistency similar to heavy cream.
• Evaporated Milk: A slightly denser substitute than regular milk but less heavy than cream. It’s suitable if you want to reduce fat content in the recipe.
• Greek Yogurt (Thinned): Mix whole-milk Greek yogurt with a bit of milk or a plant-based alternative to achieve a creamy substitute.

3. Sweetened Condensed Milk

Substitutes:

• Honey or Maple Syrup: These natural sweeteners can replicate the sweetness of condensed milk. Start with 1–2 tablespoons and adjust to taste.
• Coconut Condensed Milk: A dairy-free alternative made from coconut milk and a natural sweetener, easily found in most health food stores.
• Brown Sugar Syrup: Dissolve 2 parts brown sugar in 1 part hot water to create a substitute with a molasses-like depth of flavor.
• Dulce de Leche: This is a caramel-like spread or syrup and can replicate the sweetness/texture of condensed milk with a slightly caramelized flavor.

4. Vanilla Extract

Substitutes:

• Vanilla Bean: Scrape the seeds from half a vanilla bean pod and add them to the recipe for a more intense, natural vanilla flavor.
• Vanilla Paste: This is a thicker and flavor-packed version of vanilla extract. Use it in the same quantity as the extract.
• Maple Extract (in small amounts): While not identical to vanilla, maple extract can give your creamer a sweet and aromatic undertone with slight complexity.

5. Almond Extract

Substitutes:

• Butternut Extract: Provides a slightly nutty flavor that’s comparable to almond but with buttery notes.
• Amaretto Liqueur: Add 1 teaspoon of this sweet, almond-flavored liqueur for a luxurious twist.
• Hazelnut Extract: An alternative nut flavoring that pairs well with the overall sweet birthday cake concept.
• Omit Almond Extract: If you’re sensitive to nut flavors, you can skip this entirely. The vanilla and butter/batter flavors will still shine through.

6. Sugar

Substitutes:

• Stevia or Monk Fruit Sweetener: Zero-calorie options for those monitoring sugar intake. These are often sweeter than sugar, so use them sparingly.
• Agave Syrup: A liquid sweetener with a mild flavor; use it as a natural, plant-based alternative.
• Coconut Sugar: Adds a hint of caramel-like flavor but maintains sweetness.
• Brown Sugar: For a deeper, richer sweetness to complement the creamer flavor.

7. Butter Extract

Butter extract is an ingredient often used to replicate the flavor of buttered goodness (think “cake batter”), and while it’s useful, it isn’t mandatory!

Substitutes:

• Melted Unsalted Butter: Add 1–2 teaspoons of melted butter for a mild buttery note (best for non-dairy-free recipes).
• Brown Butter: Make a small amount of browned butter (melt and cook butter until golden and nutty) and add just a touch for an elevated flavor.
• Vanilla Extract: Doubling the vanilla extract can sometimes compensate for butter extract, as it broadens the flavor profile.
• Skip it Entirely: Sweetness and vanilla are enough to give the recipe its cake-batter charm, even without butter extract.

8. Rainbow Sprinkles (Optional)

Substitutes:

• Chocolate Sprinkles: A fun alternative for a mocha twist.
• Edible Glitter: For an extra sparkle in your coffee, edible glitter makes a unique and festive topping.
• Omit it Completely: Sprinkles are purely for decoration and fun—they won’t change the creamer flavor!

Final Thoughts

Making your own Starbucks Birthday Cake Pop Creamer is not just fun and satisfying—it’s a delicious way to personalize your coffee rituals.

More Reviews:

• Copycat Trader Joe’s Cajun Alfredo Recipe
• Copycat Shake Shack French Onion Burger Recipe
• Linda’s Fudge Cake Recipe
• Copycat Trader Joe’s Protein Pancakes Recipe